CClaimWatch
Defense counsel in 11 cases

James Francis Monagle

Mullen Coughlin LLC

Address of record
500 Capitol Mall, Suite 2350, Sacramento, CA 95814, 267-930-1529
Email
jmonagle@mullen.law
Phone
(267) 930-1529
Fax
Fax 267-930-4771

Contact details as filed with the court in the cases below.

11
Cases tracked
8 active · 3 settled
—
Plaintiff-side recovery
Disclosed settlement funds
$400,000
Defense-side exposure
Resolved in settlements
1
Cases with values
of 11 tracked

Case history

Publicly tracked matters where this attorney is listed as counsel.

Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

ServiceAide Class Action

A proposed class action was filed against ServiceAide, Inc., apparently involving personal property claims (Nature of Suit 380). The docket text does not specify the underlying allegations, but it includes motions related to consolidation and appointment of class counsel, which are typical in class litigation. The case was terminated on January 29, 2026, after ADR certification and scheduling of an initial case management conference.

Filed
May 24, 2025
Represents
ServiceAide, Inc.
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Romantix Online Consumer Fraud Class Action

A proposed class action against Romantix Online, Inc., apparently concerning fraud. The docket indicates a claim under 'Other Fraud,' but further details are not available from the caption or initial docket text. The allegations are not proven and the case has not yet resulted in a settlement.

Filed
March 11, 2025
Represents
Innov8 Solutions, Inc.
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Jamie S. Schwartz Personal Injury Class Action

A proposed class action against Jamie S. Schwartz, apparently concerning personal injury claims. The docket does not provide additional details, but the nature of suit is 'P.I.: Other.' These are allegations in a newly filed case and have not been proven.

Filed
February 3, 2025
Represents
MEDVA, LLC
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Keesal, Young & Logan Class Action

This is one of several related class actions against Keesal, Young & Logan that a federal court ordered consolidated. The nature of suit is listed as 'Contract: Other,' but the docket text does not reveal the specific facts alleged. The court has appointed interim co-lead class counsel and set a schedule for a consolidated amended complaint.

Filed
December 10, 2024
Represents
Keesal, Young and Logan
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Keesal, Young and Logan Class Action

A proposed class action against Keesal, Young and Logan, a law firm, apparently concerning claims under the 'Personal Property: Other' nature-of-suit category. The docket indicates that this case is one of several related actions against the firm and that interim co-lead class counsel have been appointed, but it does not specify the underlying allegations. The claims are allegations only and have not been proven.

Filed
December 5, 2024
Represents
Keesal, Young and Logan
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Keesal, Young & Logan Data Breach Class Action

This is a proposed class action against Keesal, Young & Logan, apparently concerning a data security incident. The consolidated class action complaint is the subject of a pending motion to dismiss, and the court recently heard oral argument and took the motion under submission. The allegations in the complaint are not proven facts and there is no settlement.

Filed
December 3, 2024
Represents
Keesal, Young & Logan
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

LA Financial Federal Credit Union Class Action

A proposed class action appears to have been filed against LA Financial Federal Credit Union. The docket text is unavailable, so the specific allegations are not described in the provided metadata, and the matter is docketed as a personal injury/other case. These are allegations in a newly filed case, not proven facts, and there is no indication of a settlement.

Filed
September 20, 2024
Represents
LA Financial Federal Credit Union
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Barnaby Ltd. Personal Injury Class Action

A newly filed putative class action against Barnaby Ltd., LLC, apparently concerning personal injury claims, based on the docket's nature of suit designation 'P.I.: Other.' The docket text does not provide specific allegations, so no further details can be inferred.

Filed
June 25, 2024
Represents
Barnaby Ltd., LLC
Defense counselSettled — claims closed

Martinez v. Choose Your Horizon - Privacy Data Disclosure Settlement

Choose Your Horizon, Inc., a ketamine therapy provider, allegedly disclosed customers' confidential and protected health information to third parties in violation of California privacy law through its websites. The defendant denies liability but agreed to settle to avoid further legal costs and uncertainty.

Settlement fund
$400,000
Claim deadline
April 23, 2026
Represents
Choose Your Horizon, Inc.
Defense counselSettled — claims closed

MOVEit Customer Data Security Breach Settlement

Cadence Bank used a third-party file transfer application called MOVEit Transfer that had a security vulnerability. This vulnerability led to a data breach between May 28, 2023 and May 31, 2023, where personally identifying information of customers was compromised. Cadence began notifying affected individuals in September 2023.

Claim deadline
June 4, 2026
Represents
Union Bank and Trust Company
Defense counselSettled — claims closed

MOVEit Nuance Data Security Breach Settlement

Nuance Communications, Inc. experienced a data security breach between May 27-31, 2023, affecting personally identifiable information of customers. The breach resulted from an alleged vulnerability in MOVEit Transfer, third-party file transfer software that Nuance used in its ordinary business operations. Nuance is settling claims related to this 2023 MOVEit Security Incident, though litigation against Progress Software Corporation (the MOVEit software licensor) continues.

Claim deadline
March 30, 2026
Represents
Union Bank and Trust Company

“Recovery” and “exposure” refer to total disclosed settlement funds in associated cases, not money personally won or lost by an attorney. Settlements generally resolve disputed allegations without a finding that either side won. Data comes from public court dockets and may be incomplete.