CClaimWatch
Defense counsel in 4 cases

John C. Babione

Constangy, Brooks, Smith & Prophete, LLP.

Address of record
201 N. Illinois Street, 16th Floor - South Tower, Indianapolis, IN 46204, 317-294-8274
Email
jbabione@constangy.com
Phone
(317) 294-8274

Contact details as filed with the court in the cases below.

4
Cases tracked
2 active · 2 settled
—
Plaintiff-side recovery
Disclosed settlement funds
$932,800
Defense-side exposure
Resolved in settlements
1
Cases with values
of 4 tracked

Case history

Publicly tracked matters where this attorney is listed as counsel.

Defense counselSettled — accepting claims

Brevard Skin & Cancer Center Data Breach Settlement

A targeted cyberattack on Brevard Skin & Cancer Center's computer systems in September 2025 accessed files containing private information, including names, dates of birth, addresses, billing and claims information, Social Security numbers, diagnosis and clinical information, phone numbers, email addresses, and health conditions. The defendant denies any wrongdoing, and the settlement is to avoid the costs and risks of continued litigation.

Claim deadline
November 16, 2026
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Phia Group Data Security Class Action

A proposed class action against Phia Group LLC arising from a data security incident. The case alleges harm to individuals whose data was apparently compromised or inadequately protected, though specific details of the breach and affected parties are not yet fully disclosed in the available docket information.

Filed
February 2, 2026
Represents
The Phia Group, LLC
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

South Western Communications Contract Class Action

A proposed class action was filed against South Western Communications, Inc. The case is designated under the nature-of-suit code for 'Contract: Other,' which suggests the plaintiff may allege breach of contract or related claims. Specific allegations are not available from the provided caption and docket text.

Filed
September 3, 2024
Represents
SOUTH WESTERN COMMUNICATIONS, INC.
Defense counselSettled — claims closed

Venture Logistics Data Breach Settlement

Venture Transportation Partners, LLC experienced a criminal ransomware attack on or around May 13, 2023, in which personally identifiable information of settlement class members may have been accessed by unauthorized third parties. Venture denies any wrongdoing and liability, but has agreed to settle the lawsuit on a class-wide basis.

Settlement fund
$932,800
Claim deadline
October 1, 2025
Represents
VENTURE TRANSPORTATION PARTNERS, LLC d/b/a VENTURE LOGISTICS

“Recovery” and “exposure” refer to total disclosed settlement funds in associated cases, not money personally won or lost by an attorney. Settlements generally resolve disputed allegations without a finding that either side won. Data comes from public court dockets and may be incomplete.