CClaimWatch
Plaintiff counsel in 5 cases

Patrick J. Vallely

Shapiro Haber & Urmy LLP

Address of record
Seaport East, 2 Seaport Lane, 6th Flr., Boston, MA 02210, 617-439-3939
Email
pvallely@shulaw.com
Phone
(617) 439-3939

Contact details as filed with the court in the cases below.

5
Cases tracked
3 active · 2 settled
$33.5M
Plaintiff-side recovery
Disclosed settlement funds
—
Defense-side exposure
Resolved in settlements
2
Cases with values
of 5 tracked

Case history

Publicly tracked matters where this attorney is listed as counsel.

Plaintiff counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Atrius Health Privacy Class Action

A proposed class action against Atrius Health, Inc., filed by pseudonymous plaintiffs. The docket indicates the case is stayed pending the First Circuit's decision in Goulart, and Atrius Health has moved to dismiss for failure to state a claim. The nature-of-suit code is 'Other Statutory Actions,' suggesting statutory claims, but the specific allegations are not detailed in the docket text.

Filed
January 3, 2025
Represents
Jane Doe
Plaintiff counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

UMass Memorial Health Care Class Action

A proposed class action against UMass Memorial Health Care, Inc. and affiliated hospitals. The docket text does not describe the specific allegations, only that plaintiffs Lisa Colleton, John Doe, and Janice Progin filed a Second Consolidated Amended Class Action Complaint under the case's 'Other Statutory Actions' designation. The claims appear to concern statutory violations, but no further details are provided in the available docket text.

Filed
January 2, 2025
Represents
Janice Progin
Plaintiff counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center Statutory Class Action

A proposed class action was filed against Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Inc. The docket text does not describe the underlying allegations, but the case involves statutory claims over which the federal court determined it lacked jurisdiction and remanded to state court. The allegations are unproven.

Filed
December 31, 2024
Represents
Kathleen Vita
Plaintiff counselSettled — claims closed

Evenflo Big Kid Booster Seat Settlement

Evenflo allegedly misled consumers by labeling and advertising its "Big Kid" booster seats as "side impact tested" and safe for children weighing 30 pounds or more, when the company claims the labeling and advertising was not misleading and denies any wrongdoing. The parties settled to avoid the cost and risk of continued litigation.

Settlement fund
$3.5M
Claim deadline
November 24, 2025
Represents
Desinae Williams, Elise Howland, Theresa Holliday
Plaintiff counselSettled — claims closed

YouTube Children's Privacy Settlement (Hubbard v. Google)

Google allegedly tracked and collected personal data about children under 13 without parental consent on YouTube. Google denies that it did anything wrong.

Settlement fund
$30M
Claim deadline
January 21, 2026
Represents
Paula Ridenti

“Recovery” and “exposure” refer to total disclosed settlement funds in associated cases, not money personally won or lost by an attorney. Settlements generally resolve disputed allegations without a finding that either side won. Data comes from public court dockets and may be incomplete.