CClaimWatch
Defense counsel in 15 cases

Ashley Lynn Shively

Holland & Knight LLP

Address of record
560 Mission Street, Ste 19th Floor, San Francisco, CA 94105, 415-743-6900
Email
ashley.shively@hklaw.com
Phone
(415) 743-6900
Fax
Fax 213-896-2450

Contact details as filed with the court in the cases below.

15
Cases tracked
13 active · 2 settled
—
Plaintiff-side recovery
Disclosed settlement funds
$127.5M
Defense-side exposure
Resolved in settlements
2
Cases with values
of 15 tracked

Case history

Publicly tracked matters where this attorney is listed as counsel.

Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Weatherly v. Cleveland Clinic Foundation

This is a proposed class action against Cleveland Clinic Foundation alleging fraud. The specific factual details of the alleged fraud are not provided in the available docket information, but the case was filed under a general fraud nature of suit code, suggesting allegations of deceptive or fraudulent conduct that could affect patients or consumers of the healthcare provider's services.

Filed
December 8, 2025
Represents
Cleveland Clinic Foundation, CLEVELAND CLINIC FLORIDA HEALTH SYSTEM NONPROFIT CORPORATION
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Dawkins v. Dow Jones & Company Data Access Class Action

This proposed class action against Dow Jones & Company, Inc. was filed on October 29, 2025. While specific allegations are not available from the docket metadata provided, the lawsuit appears to involve consumer claims arising under statutory law (classified as 'Other Statutory Actions'). Additional details about the nature and scope of the allegations would require access to the complaint itself.

Filed
October 29, 2025
Represents
Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Bath & Body Works Fraud Class Action

This proposed class action against Bath & Body Works, Inc. alleges fraud, apparently concerning the company's products, marketing, or business practices. The case was filed in October 2025 and names an individual plaintiff. Specific details of the allegations are not yet available from the docket materials provided.

Filed
October 9, 2025
Represents
Bath & Body Works, Inc.
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Wunderkind Privacy Class Action

A proposed class action has been filed alleging privacy violations by Wunderkind, apparently concerning how the company handles or uses personal information. The case was newly filed in July 2025 and is proceeding in federal court in the Southern District of New York.

Filed
July 16, 2025
Represents
Wunderkind Corporation
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Healthcare Management Solutions Class Action

A proposed class action against Healthcare Management Solutions, LLC, apparently concerning claims under personal property law. The docket text indicates the court recently issued an opinion granting in part and denying in part the defendant's motion to dismiss, and denied related protective order motions as moot.

Filed
February 10, 2025
Represents
ASRC Federal Data Solutions, LLC
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

VCA Contract Class Action

A proposed class action against VCA, Inc. was filed in federal court. The nature of suit is listed as 'Contract: Other,' and the plaintiff appears to bring contract-related claims on behalf of a class, but the docket text is unavailable, so further specifics are not stated.

Filed
January 22, 2025
Represents
VCA Inc., Mars Inc., Mars Petcare US, Inc., MMI Holdings, Inc., Medical Management International Inc.
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Forbes Media Class Action

A proposed class action was filed against Forbes Media LLC, apparently involving statutory claims. The docket text indicates the parties have reached a class action settlement and are seeking the court's preliminary approval; specific underlying allegations are not stated in the docket entries provided.

Filed
December 20, 2024
Represents
Forbes Media LLC
Defense counselSettled — accepting claims

Forbes Media Website Tracker Class Action Settlement

Forbes Media collected IP addresses and unique identifiers without consent using trackers on its websites between December 20, 2023 and June 11, 2026, and shared this data with third parties, allegedly in violation of California's Invasion of Privacy Act and Unfair Competition Law. Forbes denies these allegations and any wrongdoing.

Settlement fund
$10M
Claim deadline
November 9, 2026
Represents
Forbes Media LLC
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Abbott Laboratories Personal Injury Class Action

A proposed class action against Abbott Laboratories. The available docket text does not describe the specific allegations, but the case is docketed as a personal injury matter (Nature of Suit 360). On January 2, 2025, the plaintiff voluntarily dismissed the case without prejudice, so the allegations have not been resolved or proven.

Filed
December 6, 2024
Represents
Abbott Laboratories
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

National Rugby League Streaming Privacy Class Action

A proposed class action against National Rugby League Limited and Fox Sports entities appears to concern online streaming of rugby league content, as suggested by references to terms and conditions and privacy policies. The specific statutory allegations are not detailed in the docket text, but the case was filed under 'Other Statutory Actions' and later dismissed without prejudice.

Filed
August 9, 2024
Represents
Fox Sports Australia PTY Limited, Fox Sports Streamco PTY Limited
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Australian Football League Consumer Class Action

This is a proposed class action against the Australian Football League and Fox Sports Australia entities, apparently involving consumer claims related to sports broadcasting or streaming services. The docket text does not detail the specific allegations, but the individual plaintiffs sought to represent a class, and the defendants moved to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction and forum non conveniens. The case was voluntarily dismissed without prejudice while those motions were pending.

Filed
August 9, 2024
Represents
Fox Sports Australia PTY Limited, Fox Sports Streamco PTY Limited
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Healthcare Management Solutions Data Breach Class Action

A proposed class action against Healthcare Management Solutions, LLC, apparently concerning claims related to personal property, possibly a data breach or privacy incident involving consumers' personal information. The case was filed in the Northern District of California. The allegations are new and have not been proven.

Filed
August 1, 2024
Represents
ASRC Federal Data Solutions, LLC
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

GardaWorld CashLink Contract Class Action

A proposed class action against GardaWorld CashLink LLC was filed in California, apparently concerning a contract dispute. The available docket text does not specify the underlying allegations, and the case was later voluntarily dismissed without prejudice. These are allegations in a newly filed case, not proven facts.

Filed
May 8, 2024
Represents
GardaWorld CashLink LLC
Defense counselActive litigation — no settlement yet

Virgin Atlantic Airways Personal Injury Class Action

A proposed class action against Virgin Atlantic Airways Ltd., apparently concerning personal injury claims under the 'P.I.: Other' nature of suit. The docket text is unavailable, so the specific allegations are not detailed. These are allegations in a newly filed case, not proven facts and not yet a settlement.

Filed
April 10, 2024
Represents
Virgin Atlantic Airways Ltd.
Defense counselSettled — claims closed

Comcast Data Breach Settlement

In October 2023, a third-party gained unauthorized access to Comcast customers' personal information in a cybersecurity incident. Comcast denies that it engaged in any wrongdoing or violated any law.

Settlement fund
$117.5M
Claim deadline
September 14, 2026
Represents
COMCAST CABLE COMMUNICATIONS LLC, COMCAST CORPORATION

“Recovery” and “exposure” refer to total disclosed settlement funds in associated cases, not money personally won or lost by an attorney. Settlements generally resolve disputed allegations without a finding that either side won. Data comes from public court dockets and may be incomplete.