Liberty Mutual Total Loss Insurance Class Action
All 2 class actions against Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance →
Verified November 21, 2026Found via the federal court docketHow ClaimWatch verifies cases
Still being litigated: the claims below are allegations, not findings, and there is no settlement, claim form or payout yet.
Where this case stands
In litigation
The case has been filed and is being fought in court. There is no settlement, no claim form and no payout yet; many class actions are dismissed or never certified.
Pending in the District Court, D. Massachusetts (No. 1:23-cv-12845).
- November 21, 2023Case filed
What happened
A proposed class action against Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company, apparently concerning auto insurance claims for totaled vehicles. The lawsuit alleges that the insurer's OTEC Endorsement required an individualized determination of the time insureds reasonably needed to replace a totaled vehicle, and that the company failed to make that determination, breaching its insurance contracts. The allegations are not proven facts and the case is not yet a settlement.
Do you qualify?
No settlement exists yet, so there is nothing to file and no class definition to check. If the case settles, the settlement will define exactly who qualifies — watch this case and we'll let you know.
How to file
There is no claim to file yet. If this case reaches a settlement, a claim process will open — usually with an official settlement website and a filing deadline.
Common questions
- Can I file a claim in the Liberty Mutual Total Loss Insurance Class Action case?
- No. The case is still being litigated — there is no settlement, no claim form, and no payout. It was filed November 21, 2023 in the District Court, D. Massachusetts (No. 1:23-cv-12845).What a class action lawsuit is →
- Who are the attorneys in the Liberty Mutual Total Loss Insurance Class Action?
- For the plaintiffs: Richard M. Ochroch (Richard M. Ochroch & Assoc. P.C.); Brett N. Benton (Ochroch Benton, P.C.); Andrew R. Ochroch (Ochroch Benton, P.C.); Julie S. Selesnick (Berger Montague PC). For Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company: Jacob A. Tosti (Saul Ewing LLP); Ryan M. Jerome (Saul Ewing LLP); Stephanie L. Denker (Saul Ewing LLP); James A. Morsch (Saul Ewing LLP). From the public court docket.
Who's involved
Plaintiffs
- Adam Pizzitola
- Anthony Watts
- Diane Watts
Defendants
- Liberty Mutual Insurance Company
- Liberty Mutual Holding Company, Inc.
- LMHC Massachusetts Holdings, Inc.
- Liberty Mutual Group, Inc.
- Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company
Counsel for plaintiffs
- Richard M. OchrochRichard M. Ochroch & Assoc. P.C.Represents Diane Watts, Anthony Watts, Adam Pizzitoladosti@ochroch-law.com · (215) 735-2707
- Brett N. BentonOchroch Benton, P.C.Represents Diane Watts, Anthony Watts, Adam Pizzitolabbenton@ochroch-law.com · (215) 735-2707
- Andrew R. OchrochOchroch Benton, P.C.Represents Diane Watts, Anthony Watts, Adam Pizzitolaaochroch@ochroch-law.com · (215) 735-2707
- Julie S. SelesnickBerger Montague PCRepresents Diane Watts, Anthony Watts, Adam Pizzitola5 tracked casesjselesnick@bm.net · (202) 221-5279
- Yechiel Michael TwerskyBerger & Montague PCRepresents Diane Watts, Anthony Watts, Adam Pizzitola2 tracked casesmitwersky@bergermontague.com · (215) 875-3052
- Shanon J. CarsonBerger Montague PCRepresents Diane Watts, Anthony Watts, Adam Pizzitola11 tracked cases · $117.8M in disclosed settlementsscarson@bergermontague.com · (215) 875-3000
- John G. AlbaneseBerger Montague PCRepresents Diane Watts, Anthony Watts, Adam Pizzitola13 tracked casesjalbanese@bergermontague.com · (612) 594-5999
Counsel for defendants
- Jacob A. TostiSaul Ewing LLPRepresents Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company, Liberty Mutual Insurance Companyjacob.tosti@saul.com · (617) 912-0968
- Ryan M. JeromeSaul Ewing LLPRepresents Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company, Liberty Mutual Insurance Company2 tracked casesryan.jerome@saul.com · (212) 980-7232
- Stephanie L. DenkerSaul Ewing LLPRepresents Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company, Liberty Mutual Group, Inc., LMHC Massachusetts Holdings, Inc., Liberty Mutual Holding Company, Inc.stephanie.denker@saul.com · (212) 980-7214
- James A. MorschSaul Ewing LLPRepresents Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company, Liberty Mutual Group, Inc., LMHC Massachusetts Holdings, Inc., Liberty Mutual Holding Company, Inc.11 tracked casesjim.morsch@saul.com · (312) 876-7866
- Bridgitte E. MottSaul Ewing LLPRepresents Liberty Mutual Personal Insurance Company, Liberty Mutual Group, Inc., LMHC Massachusetts Holdings, Inc., Liberty Mutual Holding Company, Inc., Liberty Mutual Insurance Companybridgitte.mott@saul.com · (617) 912-0905
Other cases these firms appear in
- McDonald's Antitrust Class Action · Berger Montague PC
- Behm v. Volkswagen Group of America Product Liability Class Action · Berger Montague PC
- Riley v. Medtronic Medical Device Class Action · Berger Montague PC
- C&L LLC v. Cal-Maine Foods Antitrust Class Action · Berger Montague PC
- Nowell v. Verano Holdings Corp. TCPA Class Action · Saul Ewing LLP
From the public court docket, contact details as filed; not an endorsement.
Guides:What is a class action lawsuit?How class membership worksYour options as a class member
Summarised from public settlement documents; confirm terms on the official settlement website. ClaimWatch is not a law firm, and filing a claim is free.
More insurance settlements
View all →Starbucks COBRA Notice Settlement
Every Settlement Class Member who submits a valid claim form will receive their pro-rata share of the Net Settlement Fund, which shall be disbursed in full to all Settlement Class Members.