North American Company COI Settlement
Last verified September 18, 2026Source: jndHow ClaimWatch verifies cases
Closed to new claims. Browse open settlements →
Where this case stands
Final approval granted November 13, 2023
Claims closed. Once the time to appeal has run, the administrator pays valid claims; that usually takes three to twelve months after approval.
Before Judge Stephanie M. Rose (No. 4:18-cv-00368).
- October 30, 2018Case filed
- June 20, 2023Preliminary approval
The court allowed notice of the proposed settlement to go out to the class.
- October 30, 2023Opt-out and objection deadline
Last day to exclude yourself from the settlement or object to its terms.
- November 13, 2023Final approval granted
- December 1, 2023Case closed by the court
What happened
North American Company for Life and Health Insurance allegedly imposed unlawful cost of insurance (COI) charges on owners of Classic Term UL I and II life insurance policies that were not based on the company's expectations as to future mortality experience, in breach of the policy contracts. The defendant denies these claims and asserts that COI rates were set in compliance with the contract.
Do you qualify?
All current and former owners of Classic Term UL I or II life insurance policies issued or insured by North American Company for Life and Health Insurance or its predecessors, during the Class Period (which begins on various dates between October 30, 2008 and October 30, 2015, depending on the state where the policy was issued, and continues through the date of final judgment).
What you can claim
Read from the official settlement notice.
Accumulation Value Credit or Cash Payment
Class members with active policies will receive an Accumulation Value Credit on their policy(ies), or a cash payment in the mail if their policy(ies) is terminated at the time of distribution.
Who is in the class
All current and former owners of Classic Term UL I or II issued or insured by North American Company for Life and Health Insurance, or its predecessors, during the Class Period.
Quoted from the settlement notice.
How to file
If you own or owned a qualifying Classic Term UL I or II policy, you do not need to file a claim to receive benefits. Active policyholders will automatically receive an Accumulation Value Credit on their policy(ies), and those with terminated policies at the time of distribution will receive a cash payment by mail. To exclude yourself or file an objection, you must act by October 30, 2023. Contact the Settlement Administrator at 1-844-633-0709 or info@COIclassaction-na.com for more information.
Common questions
- What is the status of the North American Company COI Settlement?
- Final approval granted November 13, 2023. Claims closed. Once the time to appeal has run, the administrator pays valid claims; that usually takes three to twelve months after approval.
- Is the North American Company COI Settlement notice real, or a scam?
- JND Legal Administration is the court-appointed administrator. Claims are filed only at coiclassaction-na.com. Filing is always free, and no administrator asks for payment or a full Social Security number by email or text.How to tell a real settlement notice from a scam →
- Who are the attorneys in the North American Company COI Settlement?
- For the plaintiffs: Robin G. Maxon (HOPKINS & HUEBNER PC); Halley W. Josephs (SUSMAN GODFREY LLP (CA)); Chandler Maxon Surrency (HOPKINS & HUEBNER PC); Steven G. Sklaver (SUSMAN GODFREY LLP (CA)). For North American Company for Life and Health Insurance: Tiffany L Powers (ALSTON & BIRD LLP (GA)); Tejas Patel (ALSTON & BIRD LLP (GA)); Tania L. Rice (ALSTON & BIRD LLP (CA)); John E. Stephenson , Jr. (ALSTON & BIRD LLP (GA)). From the public court docket.
Who's involved
Plaintiffs
- PHT Holding II LLC
Defendants
- North American Company for Life and Health Insurance
Counsel for plaintiffs
- Robin G. MaxonHOPKINS & HUEBNER PCRepresents PHT Holding II LLCrmaxon@hhlawpc.com · (515) 697-4234
- Halley W. JosephsSUSMAN GODFREY LLP (CA)Represents PHT Holding II LLChjosephs@susmangodfrey.com · (310) 789-3100
- Chandler Maxon SurrencyHOPKINS & HUEBNER PCRepresents PHT Holding II LLCcsurrency@hhlawpc.com · (515) 697-4302
- Steven G. SklaverSUSMAN GODFREY LLP (CA)Represents PHT Holding II LLC2 tracked cases · $18.5M in disclosed settlementsssklaver@susmangodfrey.com · (310) 789-3100
- Seth ArdSUSMAN GODFREY LLP (NY)Represents PHT Holding II LLCsard@susmangodfrey.com · (212) 336-8330
- Ryan C. KirkpatrickSUSMAN GODFREY LLP (NY)Represents PHT Holding II LLCrkirkpatrick@susmangodfrey.com · (212) 336-8330
- Nicholas N. SpearSUSMAN GODFREY LLP (CA)Represents PHT Holding II LLC2 tracked cases · $18.5M in disclosed settlementsnspear@susmangodfrey.com · (310) 789-3108
- Michael BrightmanSUSMAN GODFREY LLP (TX)Represents PHT Holding II LLCmbrightman@susmangodfrey.com · (713) 651-9366
- Lora J. KrsulichSUSMAN GODFREY LLP (CA)Represents PHT Holding II LLClkrsulich@susmangodfrey.com · (310) 789-3145
- Krysta Kauble PachmanSUSMAN GODFREY LLP (CA)Represents PHT Holding II LLC2 tracked cases · $18.5M in disclosed settlementskpachman@susmangodfrey.com · (310) 789-3100
- Hannah C. WaiteSUSMAN GODFREY LLP (NY)Represents PHT Holding II LLChwaite@susmangodfrey.com · (212) 336-8330
- Glenn C. BridgmanSUSMAN GODFREY LLP (CA)Represents PHT Holding II LLCgbridgman@susmangodfrey.com · (310) 789-3104
- R. Ronald PoggeHOPKINS & HUEBNER PCRepresents PHT Holding II LLCrpogge@hhlawpc.com · (515) 697-4268
Counsel for defendants
- Tiffany L PowersALSTON & BIRD LLP (GA)Represents North American Company for Life and Health Insurancetiffany.powers@alston.com · (404) 881-4249
- Tejas PatelALSTON & BIRD LLP (GA)Represents North American Company for Life and Health Insurancetejas.patel@alston.com · (404) 881-4987
- Tania L. RiceALSTON & BIRD LLP (CA)Represents North American Company for Life and Health Insurancetania.rice@alston.com · (415) 243-1000
- John E. Stephenson , Jr.ALSTON & BIRD LLP (GA)Represents North American Company for Life and Health Insurancejohn.stephenson@alston.com · (404) 881-7697
- Alan PryorALSTON & BIRD LLP (GA)Represents North American Company for Life and Health Insurancealan.pryor@alston.com · (404) 881-7000
- Thomas A. EvansALSTON & BIRD LLP (CA)Represents North American Company for Life and Health Insurance2 tracked casestom.evans@alston.com · (415) 243-1000
- Max Paul MarksALSTON & BIRD LLP (GA)Represents North American Company for Life and Health Insurancemax.marks@alston.com · (404) 881-7853
- Andrew G. PhillipsALSTON & BIRD LLP (GA)Represents North American Company for Life and Health Insuranceandrew.phillips@alston.com · (404) 881-7183
- William H. HigginsALSTON & BIRD LLPRepresents North American Company for Life and Health Insurance2 tracked caseswilliam.higgins@alston.com · (704) 444-1000
- Samuel J. ParkALSTON & BIRD LLPRepresents North American Company for Life and Health Insurance2 tracked casessamuel.park@alston.com · (213) 576-2687
- Rachel Adi NaorALSTON & BIRD LLP (CA)Represents North American Company for Life and Health Insurancerachel.naor@alston.com · (415) 243-1000
- Andrew J. TuckALSTON & BIRD LLP (GA)Represents North American Company for Life and Health Insurance2 tracked casesandy.tuck@alston.com · (404) 881-7134
- Michael A. DeeBROWN WINICK GRAVES GROSS AND BASKERVILLE P.L.C.Represents North American Company for Life and Health Insurancemichael.dee@brownwinick.com · (515) 242-2400
Other cases these firms appear in
- PHL Variable Life COI Settlement · SUSMAN GODFREY LLP (CA)
- Oracle Health Personal Injury Class Action · ALSTON & BIRD LLP (GA)
- Midland National Life Insurance RICO Class Action · ALSTON & BIRD LLP (GA)
- Mohawk Industries Flooring Product Defect Class Action · ALSTON & BIRD LLP (GA)
- Porsche Cars N.A. Consumer Fraud Class Action · ALSTON & BIRD LLP (GA)
From the public court docket, contact details as filed; not an endorsement.
Guides:Why is my settlement check so small?How long a settlement takes to pay outIs this settlement notice real, or a scam?
Summarised from public settlement documents; confirm terms on the official settlement website. ClaimWatch is not a law firm, and filing a claim is free.