Varney v. American Family Mutual Insurance Company Settlement
This settlement is closed to new claims — the deadline was October 10, 2025. You can still see what it was about and follow the case in court below. Looking for money you can still claim? Browse open settlements →
What happened
American Family Mutual Insurance Company allegedly improperly deducted Nonmaterial Depreciation when adjusting certain structural loss claims for Missouri policyholders. The company is paying to settle whether these deductions were proper.
Do you qualify?
Anyone who had a structural damage insurance claim with American Family Mutual Insurance Company in Missouri that was adjusted between April 27, 2012 and April 27, 2017.
How to file
You must submit a valid Claim Form to receive payment. The deadline to submit a claim has passed (October 10, 2025). Please read the Class Notice and check the Frequently Asked Questions page for more information about the claim process and requirements.
Common questions
- What is the claim deadline for the Varney v. American Family Mutual Insurance Company Settlement?
- This settlement is closed to new claims — the deadline was October 10, 2025. Once a claim deadline passes you generally forfeit your share, even if you qualified.
- Is the Varney v. American Family Mutual Insurance Company Settlement notice real, or a scam?
- Claims are filed at varneyvamericanfamilysettlement.com. Filing a class action claim is always free — no legitimate settlement charges you to claim, and no administrator will ask for payment, a gift card, or your full Social Security number by email or text. If a notice asks for any of those, it is not from the administrator. When in doubt, ignore the link you were sent and go to the official settlement website directly.
- When will payments from the Varney v. American Family Mutual Insurance Company Settlement be sent?
- Class action payouts typically take 12 to 24 months after the claim deadline, and longer if the settlement is appealed. The final approval hearing for this case is set for August 26, 2025; no payments can be issued before a settlement receives final approval.
In the news
- Coronavirus Is Making Insurance Companies Huge Profits. Here's Why That's a Good Thing.The National Interest · May 2, 2020
- Darn Those Greedy Insurance CompaniesCato.org · April 30, 2020
- Berkshire Hathaway's Geico to credit its vehicle policyholdersMarketWatch · April 7, 2020
- Matching Endorsement Upheld as Modifying Policy to Exclude Coverage for Undamaged MaterialPropertyinsurancecoveragelaw.com · June 1, 2019
Headlines via NewsAPI. ClaimWatch isn't affiliated with these publications.
New to class actions?
This summary was generated from public settlement documents and may contain errors. Confirm eligibility, deadlines, and payment terms on the official settlement website before filing. ClaimWatch is not a law firm and this is not legal advice. Filing a claim is free.
More insurance settlements
View all →Anthem Grandfathered Rx Settlement
Anthem denied coverage for brand name (single source) prescription drugs and/or applied a deductible to these drugs under certain grandfathered health plans, resulting in out-of-pocket expenses for members and charging some members an $8,850 deductible. The California Department of Insurance required Anthem to settle this matter.
Up to $8,850
LADR Surgery Settlement
Aetna Life Insurance Company denied coverage for single-level lumbar artificial disc replacement (L-ADR) surgeries, claiming they were experimental or investigational. The settlement requires Aetna to reconsider coverage decisions and provide relief to members who were wrongly denied.
Up to $55,000