Orange County Constitutional Class Action
Verified November 19, 2026Found via the federal court docketHow ClaimWatch verifies cases
Still being litigated: the claims below are allegations, not findings, and there is no settlement, claim form or payout yet.
Where this case stands
In litigation
The case has been filed and is being fought in court. There is no settlement, no claim form and no payout yet; many class actions are dismissed or never certified.
Pending in the District Court, S.D. New York (No. 7:23-cv-10770).
- December 11, 2023Case filed
What happened
A proposed class action against Orange County, New York, apparently concerning a constitutional challenge to a New York state statute, as indicated by the nature of suit 'Constitutional - State Statute.' The docket reflects consolidation with a related case and pending motions to dismiss. The available metadata does not specify the statute or relief sought.
Do you qualify?
No settlement exists yet, so there is nothing to file and no class definition to check. If the case settles, the settlement will define exactly who qualifies — watch this case and we'll let you know.
How to file
There is no claim to file yet. If this case reaches a settlement, a claim process will open — usually with an official settlement website and a filing deadline.
Common questions
- Can I file a claim in the Orange County Constitutional Class Action case?
- No. The case is still being litigated — there is no settlement, no claim form, and no payout. It was filed December 11, 2023 in the District Court, S.D. New York (No. 7:23-cv-10770).What a class action lawsuit is →
- Who are the attorneys in the Orange County Constitutional Class Action?
- For the plaintiffs: George F. Carpinello (Boies Schiller Flexner LLP); Gregory P. Hansel (Preti Flaherty Beliveau & Pachios, LLP); Paul L. Leclair (LeClair Korona Giordano Cole LLP); Steven Edward Cole (Adams Leclair LLP). For Orange County, New York: Steven Paul Nonkes (Harris Beach PLLC (Pittsford)); Neal Louis Slifkin (Harris Beach PLLC); H. Todd Todd Bullard (Harris Beach PLLC); Yuval Rubinstein (NYS Office of The Attorney General). From the public court docket.
Who's involved
Plaintiffs
- Alexasandr Mkrtchyan
- Rodney R. Fergus
- Timothy Shawn O'Hara
Defendants
- Heidi Seelbach
- Dutchess County, New York
- State of New York
- Kerry Gallagher
- Orange County, New York
Counsel for plaintiffs
- George F. CarpinelloBoies Schiller Flexner LLPRepresents Timothy Shawn O'Hara, Rodney R. Fergus, Alexasandr Mkrtchyangcarpinello@bsfllp.com · (518) 434-0600
- Gregory P. HanselPreti Flaherty Beliveau & Pachios, LLPRepresents Rodney R. Fergus, Alexasandr Mkrtchyan6 tracked cases · $17.5M in disclosed settlementsghansel@preti.com · (207) 791-3000
- Paul L. LeclairLeClair Korona Giordano Cole LLPRepresents Timothy Shawn O'Harapleclair@adamsleclair.law · (585) 327-4100
- Steven Edward ColeAdams Leclair LLPRepresents Timothy Shawn O'Hara2 tracked casesscole@adamsleclair.law · (585) 327-4100
- Robert Yawman , IIIAdams LeclairRepresents Timothy Shawn O'Hara, Rodney R. Fergus4 tracked casesryawman@adamsleclair.law · (585) 327-4100
- Shmuel S KleinmanDworken & Bernstein Co., L.P.A.Represents Timothy Shawn O'Hara4 tracked casesskleinman@dworkenlaw.com · (440) 352-3391
- Ronald P. FriedbergMeyers, Roman, Friedberg & LewisRepresents Timothy Shawn O'Hara2 tracked casesrfriedberg@meyersroman.com · (216) 831-0042
- R. Scott HeasleyBrennan Manna & DiamondRepresents Timothy Shawn O'Hara2 tracked casesrsheasley@bmdllc.com · (216) 428-4718
- Peter TurnerMeyers, Roman, Friedberg & LewisRepresents Timothy Shawn O'Hara2 tracked casespturner@meyersroman.com · (216) 831-0042
- Patrick J. PerottiDworken & Bernstein Co., LPARepresents Timothy Shawn O'Hara, Rodney R. Fergus, Alexasandr Mkrtchyan7 tracked casespperotti@dworkenlaw.com · (440) 352-3391
- Patrick BrickmanDworken & Bernstein Co., LPARepresents Timothy Shawn O'Hara5 tracked casespbrickman@dworkenlaw.com · (440) 352-3391
- Nicole T. FiorelliDworken & Bernstein Co., L.P.A.Represents Timothy Shawn O'Hara5 tracked casesnfiorelli@dworkenlaw.com · (440) 352-3391
- Frank BartelaDworken & Bernstein Co. L.P.A.Represents Timothy Shawn O'Hara4 tracked casesfbartela@dworkenlaw.com · (440) 352-3391
Counsel for defendants
- Steven Paul NonkesHarris Beach PLLC (Pittsford)Represents Dutchess County, New York, Heidi Seelbachsnonkes@harrisbeach.com · (585) 419-8847
- Neal Louis SlifkinHarris Beach PLLCRepresents Dutchess County, New York, Heidi Seelbachnslifkin@harrisbeach.com · (585) 419-8636
- H. Todd Todd BullardHarris Beach PLLCRepresents Dutchess County, New York, Heidi Seelbachtbullard@harrisbeach.com · (585) 419-8696
- Yuval RubinsteinNYS Office of The Attorney GeneralRepresents State of New Yorkyuval.rubinstein@ag.ny.gov · (212) 416-8673
- Matthew Joseph NothnagleOrange County District Attorney's OfficeRepresents Orange County, New York, Kerry Gallaghermnothnagle@orangecountygov.com · (845) 291-3150
Other cases these firms appear in
- Flex Finance TCPA Class Action · Boies Schiller Flexner LLP
- Molchonova v. FirstBank of Puerto Rico · Boies Schiller Flexner LLP
- Doe v. Bank of America Class Action · Boies Schiller Flexner LLP
- Epiq Systems Class Action · Boies Schiller Flexner LLP
- Clean Harbors Environmental Services Labor Class Action · Preti Flaherty Beliveau & Pachios, LLP
From the public court docket, contact details as filed; not an endorsement.
Guides:What is a class action lawsuit?How class membership worksYour options as a class member
Summarised from public settlement documents; confirm terms on the official settlement website. ClaimWatch is not a law firm, and filing a claim is free.
More other settlements
View all →Charlotte Motor Speedway Landfill Settlement
SELA Realty Investments Tenant Security Deposit Settlement
60% of your security deposit, plus debt relief of any outstanding balance owed to Defendant to $0 if you moved out prior to December 31, 2024.
LaVista Fire Settlement
Up to $2,500