Crutcher v. Liberty Mutual Insurance UIM Settlement
Underinsured motorist claimants receive cash payment; UM/UIM policy holders receive partial premium refund
This settlement is closed to new claims — the deadline was April 30, 2026. You can still see what it was about and follow the case in court below. Looking for money you can still claim? Browse open settlements →
What happened
Liberty Mutual and Safeco allegedly reduced or "offset" underinsured motorist (UIM) claims by the amount paid by at-fault drivers in accidents between October 2010 and March 2022. The company is settling the class action by paying $6.5 million to affected policyholders and providing partial premium refunds to those who purchased UM/UIM coverage during the class period.
Do you qualify?
Anyone who had a New Mexico automobile insurance policy with Liberty Mutual or Safeco containing UM/UIM motorist coverage between October 1, 2010 and March 31, 2022, and/or filed an underinsured motorist claim that was reduced or offset by at-fault driver payments during that period.
How to file
Submit a Claim Form by April 30, 2026 (deadline has passed). Claimants with UIM claims must provide documentation of their claim; those with UM/UIM policies will receive direct premium refunds. Call 1-877-684-5777 for more information or visit the settlement website.
New to class actions?
This summary was generated from public settlement documents and may contain errors. Confirm eligibility, deadlines, and payment terms on the official settlement website before filing. ClaimWatch is not a law firm and this is not legal advice. Filing a claim is free.
More insurance settlements
View all →State Farm Auto Insurance Settlement
State Farm allegedly breached its auto insurance policies by failing to pay full purchasing fees for total loss claims, including Alabama state and county sales taxes, ad valorem taxes and fees, and license/tag/school fees. State Farm denies any fault or wrongdoing.
Up to $20.50
ALFA Mutual Insurance Company Total Loss Settlement
ALFA Mutual Insurance Company allegedly failed to fully reimburse settlement class members for taxes and title/registration transfer fees ("Purchasing Fees") on their total loss auto insurance claims. The defendant denies all liability, including that it failed to fully pay taxes on all total loss claims.
Up to $24
State Farm Total Loss Litigation
State Farm Mutual Automobile Ins. Co. allegedly paid its insureds in Arkansas less than the actual cash value of their total loss vehicles. A settlement has been reached with total payments of $15,583,700 available to the entire settlement class.
Pro rata percentage of the Typical Negotiation Adjustment for covered total loss claims
Anthem Grandfathered Rx Settlement
Anthem denied coverage for brand name (single source) prescription drugs and/or applied a deductible to these drugs under certain grandfathered health plans, resulting in out-of-pocket expenses for members and charging some members an $8,850 deductible. The California Department of Insurance required Anthem to settle this matter.
Up to $8,850